Showing posts with label Constitution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Constitution. Show all posts

Friday, June 30, 2017

SCOTUS Neil Gorsuch on Marriage Equality and LGBTQ Rights



Neil Gorsuch was sworn in as the 113th Supreme Court Justice on April 10, 2017. As a nominee in Neil Gorsuch’s hearing before the United States Senate he said that the law making same-sex marriage legal was “absolutely settled law” but added “there is ongoing litigation about its impact and its application right now”. Beyond that he said he could not share his personal views.

When asked during his confirmation hearing in the Senate Judiciary Committee if he would support the rights of gays and lesbians he said, “No one is looking to return us to horse and buggy days. We’re trying to interpret the law faithfully, taking principles that are enduring and a Constitution that was meant to last ages and apply it and interpret it to today’s problems”.

Earlier, Gorsuch was asked about the anti-gay views of his mentor at Oxford. Gorsuch said one only need to look at his record to see his views. When asked: “What about LGBTQ individuals?” Gorsuch snapped back: “What about them? They’re people.” “I’ve tried to treat each case and each person as a person, Gorsuch added, angrily, “not a ‘this kind of person,’ not a ‘that kind of person’ – a person.  It is a radical promise in the history of mankind.” When asked if that refers to sexual orientation, Gorsuch snapped, “the Supreme Court of the United States has held that single-sex marriage is protected by the Constitution.”

Both conservative originalists and liberal originalists have concluded that the 14th Amendment protects same-sex couples’ right to marry. But Gorsuch appears to disagree. In a 2005 National Review, Gorsuch mocked the court battle for same-sex marriage as a political fight dressed in constitutional garb. His comments on same-sex marriage itself are discouraging enough that it seems safe to assume he’s a skeptic of related rights and privileges. And his desire to accommodate corporations’ religious beliefs – even when they burden employees—raises the possibility that he would let religious businesses discriminate against same-sex couples.

Justice Gorsuch will probably not position himself as an openly anti-LGBTQ culture warrior in the mode of Justice Samuel Alito. But his more pleasant demeanor will not change the impact of his votes. And barring some kind of profound jurisprudential evolution, Gorsuch should be a consistent vote against gay and trans rights. From questioning the constitutional necessity of same-sex marriage to accepting pretextual defenses of trans bathroom exclusion, Gorsuch has repeatedly declined to defend the equal dignity of LGBTQ people. For a conservative, he may stake out some admirably unorthodox positions on the bench. But an embrace of LGBTQ rights will not be one of them.



Saturday, February 28, 2015

Equality for LGBT People



Equality before the law is an American value articulated in our Constitution. The struggle for equal rights in the United States is a dilemma that has helped shape our society into what it is today. We are on the cusp of recognizing the inherent need for equality in more than just skin color, gender or religion. Our growing understanding of what it means to discriminate, and the damage it inflicts, is enhanced with each passing year and has grown to reflect our collective understanding of freedom for all. However, lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) people today are denied many of the basic rights that most Americans enjoy and continue to be treated unfairly because of their sexual orientation or gender identity.

There has recently been successful movement forward in the areas of student non-discrimination, employment non-discrimination, hate crimes, immigration and LGBT partner benefits. The scale is tipping in our country toward the perception that LGBT people deserve equal human rights. Each of these areas of discrimination are addressed more in depth below.

Our nation's schools should be a place of study and social growth, preparing youth for the challenges of an ever-changing world. Unfortunately, students who are or perceived to be gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgender are discriminated against every day. These individuals are subject to harassment, bullying, intimidation and violence. Numerous studies have demonstrated that discrimination in schools has contributed to high rates of absenteeism, dropout, adverse health consequences, and academic underachievement among LGBT youth. For a demographic that already faces higher than average suicide rates, it should be a top priority to engender a scholastic environment where every student can feel safe and encouraged. While current Federal statutes affords protected status to students on the basis of their race, gender, color, national origin, religion, and disability, they fail to provide civil protections explicitly based on sexual orientation or gender identity.


Countless qualified and hardworking Americans are denied job opportunities, fired, or other wise discriminated against just because they are lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender. Currently, there fails to be a federal law that consistently protects LGBT individuals from employment discrimination, and as a result, they face serious mistreatment in the work force. The Employment Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA) would provide basic protections against workplace discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity. ENDA affords all Americans basic employment protection from discrimination based on irrational prejudice. It extends federal employment discrimination protections already in place for race, religion, sex, national origin, age and disability to include sexual orientation and gender identity.

Hate crimes occur every day and in every state, perpetuating a climate of fear in minority communities--including the LGBT community. What makes these crimes so odious is that they are not just crimes against an individual; they are crimes against entire communities and the very values and ideals upon which our country was founded. Making matters worse, most local law enforcement agencies currently lack the necessary resources to effectively investigate and prosecute hate crimes based on sexual orientation or gender identity/expression.

Right now, U.S. citizens and legal permanent residents may sponsor their spouses (and other immediate family members) for immigration purposes. However, same-sex partners of U.S. citizens and permanent residents are not considered "spouses," and their partners cannot sponsor them for family-based immigration. 

In June 2009, President Obama called for equal employment benefits for federal employees and issued an executive memorandum that granted some benefits to employees' same-sex partners. It is time that the federal government steps up and recognizes the miscarriage of justice happening in its own backyard. A large and growing number of America's major corporations, as well as state and local governments and educational institutions, have extended their employee benefit programs to cover their employees' committed domestic partners. 

The fact that LGBT individuals are not allowed basic human rights is a concept that is rapidly changing in our country. Equality for all people is supposedly our given right in the Constitution. We live in an interesting time as the LGBT community finds its way toward protection from discrimination and inequality. We still have a long way to go. Hate toward us is still intense and grows in some states exponentially as rights are given. The general climate of the country seems to be becoming more accepting and open to equality for LGBTs. As equality and non-discrimination become more widely given we will be able live in this country more freely and safely. 


Friday, January 23, 2015

US Supreme Court Agrees to Hear Same-Sex Cases


The United States Supreme Court justices have agreed to decide a major civil rights question: whether same-sex couples have a right to marry everywhere in America under the Constitution. The court will take up gay-rights cases that ask it to overturn bans in four states and declare for the entire nation that people may marry the partners of their choice, regardless of gender. The cases will be argued in April, and a decision is expected by late June.

The court chose not to decide this issue in 2013, even as it struck down part of a federal anti-gay marriage law that paved the way for a wave of lower court rulings across the country in favor of same-sex marriage rights. At that time, just 12 states and the District of Columbia permitted gay and lesbian couples to wed. That number has jumped to 36, almost all because of lower court rulings.

The appeals before the court come from gay and lesbian plaintiffs in Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Tennessee. The federal appeals court that oversees those four states uphold their same-sex marriage bans in November, reversing pro-gay rights rulings of federal judges in all four states. It was the first, and so far only, appellate court to rule against same-sex marriage since the high court’s 2013 decision.

On the other side, advocates for traditional marriage want the court to let the political process play out, rather than have judges order states to allow same-sex couples to marry. In October, five states asked the court to step in to preserve their bans on same-sex marriage. The justices declined without an explanation and subsequently refused to block lower court rulings from taking effect in other states while appeals were pending. Now there are just 14 states in which same-sex couples cannot wed.

The court’s decision to get involved is another marker of the rapid change that has redefined societal norms in the space of a generation. The court will be weighing in on major gay rights issues for the fourth time in 27 years. The court will be weighing in on major gay rights issues for the fourth time in27 years. In the first of those, in 1986, the court upheld Georgia’s anti-sodomy law in a devastating defeat for gay rights advocates. But the three subsequent rulings, all written by Justice Anthony Kennedy, were major victories for gay men and lesbians. In its most recent case in 2013, the court struck down part of a federal anti-gay marriage law in a decision that has paved the way for a wave of lower court rulings across the country in favor of same-sex marriage rights.


The court is extending the time it usually allots for argument from an hour to two-and-a-half hours. The justices will consider two related questions. The first is whether the Constitution requires states to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. The other is whether states must recognize same-sex marriages performed elsewhere.

Saturday, February 22, 2014

Gay Marriage and Obama


Three federal judges have now ruled that state bans on same-sex marriage violate the Constitution’s “equal protection” clause. President Barack Obama seems to disagree.

He has repeatedly stated that, while he personally supports same-sex marriage, the issue should be left to the states. In other words, the nation’s first black president holds a states-rights position on what has shaped up to be the civil-rights issue of this generation.

Most states ban same-sex marriage. And if they are left to work out the issue for themselves in the years and decades to come some will likely reverse their bans, but many won’t. The question will remain: Are same-sex marriages protected under the 14th Amendment?

It’s hard to imagine that Obama, a former constitutional law professor who has cited the 14th Amendment when discussing gay rights, believes that the equal-protection clause does not apply to gay and lesbian couples seeking a government-issued marriage license. More likely, he has taken a go-slow approach to avoid alienating constituencies—and inflaming the opposition.

His caution has been understandable perhaps even helpful in the short run. But it will become increasingly difficult for him to avoid taking a clear stand. Marriage equality is likely to come before the U.S. Supreme Court before the end of his term, possibly within the next year. At that time Obama will have to decide whether to support the plaintiffs.

He should, and he should not wait for the court to force his hand.

The presidential bully pulpit has been a powerful force in acceleration the evolution of freedom and equal rights in America, and the energy with which presidents have used their platform – or not—shapes their legacy.

In 1957, President Dwight Eisenhower declined to speak out in favor of civil rights, saying, “I don’t know what another speech would do about it right now.” In response, Martin Luther King Jr. and the Southern Negro Leaders Conference sent a telegram urging him to “use the weight of your great office to point out to the people the rights of all human beings.”

While a strong case can be made that history has so far under-appreciated Eisenhower’s record on civil rights, his unwillingness to make energetic use of his office is widely accepted as a failure.

President John F. Kennedy is still faulted for waiting two and a half years to fully embrace the cause of civil rights. When he finally did, in an Oval Office speech in June 1963, he cast the issue in terms of morality and American values. And while this may have angered opponents, it inspired more hope than hate. It became a turning point in the civil-rights movement and saved his presidency from history’s harsh judgment.

This Congress is hardly likely to pass a low prohibiting discrimination in the granting of marriage licenses. But that should not stop this president from addressing a controversial question. If Obama believes that the 14th Amendment protects same-sex marriage, he should explain why he has changed his own mind. It is an argument that Americans – who polls show favor legalizing same-sex marriage – are increasingly ready to accept. If he makes the case in a tone of respect toward opponents and if he tempers proponents’ optimism by acknowledging the lengthy nature of civil-rights movements, he can help soften the fallout from the eventual Supreme Court decision, whatever it may be.

For a president so stymied by an obstructive Congress, an Oval Office address on same-sex marriage could be a high point of his tenure. It would also be a fitting way for a barrier-breaking president to secure his place among leaders who have pushed to extend the full rights of the Constitution to all Americans.